Strengths and Weaknesses

When you review a paper for a conference or journal, many of the reviewing forms request that the reviewer outline the paper's strengths and weaknesses.Recently, I read a review that went something like this:"Weaknesses:  Several of the main findings presented in this paper are merely confirmation of previous work."I wish this was one of those publication venues where you can review the reviewers, because I would have written back:"Weaknesses: Reviewer...